Sargent's Cakes

check icon 4.4 (15)

Reviews for Sargent's Cakes (15)

Write a review
4.4
15 reviews
5 star icon
9
4 star icon
3
3 star icon
3
2 star icon
0
1 star icon
0
Service Rating
4.4
Quality Rating
4.6
Value Rating
4.2
24 May 2022
Service Rating
3.0
Quality Rating
3.0
Value Rating
3.0

Not a bad pie. Large range to choose from.

verified email - 08 Apr 2021
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

Sargent's Cakes has a great selection of donuts, cakes, and quiches. I will go as far as to say that they have the best pies in Melbourne.

verified email - 12 Aug 2013
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

This shop has been around for many years and only keeps getting better everytime i go there affordable and excellent quality pies n pastries taste amazing and cakes baked and taste so light and yummy.

verified email - 20 Jun 2013
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

While the cake decorating isn't up to any masterchef standards, the taste is all you need. Freshiest cakes ever and they open early so you can get a park easy and pick up your cake on the way to work - thanks!

verified email - 25 Sep 2012
Service Rating
4.0
Quality Rating
4.0
Value Rating
4.0

I have ordered a cake from this store on the recommendation of a family member who says they have the best cakes.

I ordered a choc mud cake which was absolutely delicious and not too rich as mud cakes can be.

The cake was well presented and decorated, so I was happy.

alanh6
#1 in Reservoir North VIC
1 review · 405 points
23 Jul 2012
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

Purchased a variety of Pies Pasties, and cakes. Great value and everything tastes so good. Always Fresh but get there early. Show your Seniors Card for your discount.

Approximate cost: $50.00

verified email - 09 Sep 2010
Service Rating
3.0
Quality Rating
4.0
Value Rating
2.0

Cakes are very nice but overpriced.
Pies are good, pasties not so.
Service okay, although having their cakes sitting in the unrefrigerated window exposed to flies is unappealing.

Approximate cost: $12

melissav 18 Oct 2010

Flies make the food tasier

elishac1 29 May 2012

I've only been here a few times and enjoyed my treats I picked... I always go for the mini option and think they're well priced. Staff can be a bit abrupt while you make your selection. Overall recommend

verified email - 04 Aug 2010
Service Rating
4.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
4.0

great cakes and pies prices are high but well worth it go there early though will sell out by lunchtime the chocolate eclairs are to die for it

christines12
1 review · 0 points
25 May 2010
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

I bought cakes, pies and slices for our business meeting of 10 ladies recently and OMG they were so good. Everything is made with fresh cream and very home made old fashion baking

Approximate cost: $80

gerdiep 11 Aug 2010

eventhough i dont live in melb anymore, i have very sweet memories of that store and its produce,,Mmmmmmmmmmm.

verified email - 22 Jan 2010
Service Rating
3.0
Quality Rating
4.0
Value Rating
3.0

big range of cakes etc... BUT staff aren't very friendly at all and because the window where all the cakes are isn't enclosed you always see flies hanging around in there. Not very appealing. I have bought bday cakes from there too. they are really great but a little expensive.

Approximate cost: $5

verified email - 06 Nov 2009
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

Fresh, yummy cakes and savory fare. Their window display is drool-worthy! Good value and everything taste homemade. The sponges, bee-stings, cream kisses and jam donuts are highly recommended.

verified email - 23 Oct 2009
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
3.0

The cakes are amazing, they taste delicious and look fantastic. My husband loves the freshly made pies and sausage rolls, I have not had one yet. The donuts are to die for, and even the bread taste's really good.

verified email - 19 Feb 2009
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

I have been buying my cakes from them for well over 35 years and I would not go anywhere else, would recommend them to everybody looking for birthday cakes etc.

verified email - 16 Feb 2008
Service Rating
5.0
Quality Rating
4.0
Value Rating
4.0

Very good value cakes which are not too pricey. Bought a bday cake here just recently and found the service and product to be very good. Would definately go back there again in future.

verified email - 17 Jan 2008
Service Rating
4.0
Quality Rating
5.0
Value Rating
5.0

I have been buying cakes (single serves) and birthday cakes from sargent's for many years....They would have to be the best in the northern suburbs of melbourne at the least

Approximate cost: $depends