We had our wedding cake made by Three Sweeties. It was awesome!
We wanted a golliwog (long story). Well - the cake was just awesome. Looked and tasted great. We had loads of comments on it - and it was actually a really nice addition to the decorations.
We met with Three Sweeties to discuss what we wanted - and also get some ideas from them (they are the experts after all) - and between us - we got a great cake.
They also made two free egg-free cupcakes for attendees with allegies which was much appreciate by those guests.

Approximate cost: $500