16 reviews about Maxy's Restaurant

Anonymous
verified email - 26 Nov 2009

I recently went to Maxy's with a large group (approximately 30 people) for dinner. We had a booking for 7.30pm, we didn't receive menu's until 9.00pm when we were told very rudely by the waiter/manager that as the kitchen couldn't cater for such a large number of a la carte meals we had to share the meat platters. None of this was advised when making the booking. Quite a number of our group had specific dietary requirements and when advising the waiter of this we were informed that "oh well, order what you want then, but I don't know what time you're gonna get it". The restaurant was not even half full!
As by this stage we were quite hungry - and not wanting to wait much longer I ordered the trio of dips with extra pita bread. What arrived (an hour later) was three separate piles of the same dip and no extra bread!
Half of our group had already left by then - without any dinner.
Will never be visiting this restaurant again.

Approximate cost: $25.00

barbarac6 13 Mar 2011

Hi, I've been eating at Maxy's for at least 20 years. They began in Chapel St, Prahran don't know what year. They moved to Kooyong Rd Caulfield, don't know what year and then to Elsternwick. I can't say one bad thing about them. I've never had a bad experience. I don't know who the owner is or even if it is the same one since Chapel St, all I know is they have really nice food, large servings at a great price, for what you get. I'm a vego and they make the BEST felafel in Melbourne. All my friends now go there since I took them and we all love it. We wouldn't go back if we had your experience, so I do understand. Just wanted you to know it's all been good for us. Everytime in everyway. Kind regards Barbara

verified email - 06 May 2009

I've only been here once for dessert on the way home. The place was pretty empty but the service was very slack. Had a sticky date pudding that certainly wasn't amongst the best I've had. The whole place is pretty tacky - reminds me of something out of the 80's (don't think the interior has been updated since then!). I think people go there for the big serves, haven't tried the mains so I can't comment on the quality.

verified email - 25 Feb 2009

Excellent restaurant with a great atmosphere. Exceptional service, friendly staff and fantastic food. I would recommend the ribs, delicious and a house specialty. Fantastic value for money.

Approximate cost: $25.00

Anonymous
verified email - 01 Mar 2008

What a top restaurant. Me and my family just come here all the time and we all love it. The food is beautiful and there is always enough to go around. Very nice surroundings + Good food= Satisfied customer!

verified email - 14 Jun 2007

Great place for carnivores

Great place for carnivores

We've been here lots of times with friends. Very casual and a great place to go if you're really hungry.

Approximate cost: $25

verified email - 12 Jun 2007

The biggest plates you've ever seen

The biggest plates you've ever seen

One of the funniest experiences is watching people visit Maxy's for the first time. They don't realise (nor do management inform them) that it's physically impossible for 1 person to finish a main course so they sit there with huge plates of food on their table trying to get through it all.

The main courses are around $28 but you can easily share that between 2. This place is great for larger groups (e.g. birthday get togethers) because you can order a couple of Mixed Grill platters and it will feed an army. The ribs are fantastic and the chicken schnitzel and calamari come in vast quantities. Ask for the mushroom sauce on your schnitzel. Not sure who Maxy is...

Approximate cost: $16

Write a review

Business Owners

Want more customers? Join the Happy Customers Program to promote your business with word-of-mouth.

Get a professional looking profile with no advertisements, access tools to attract more customer reviews, receive free marketing materials, use the Live Reviews Widget on your website, plus lots more...

See how it works

Upgrade Your Account